Complementary Technologies Make MQL More Accessible

Minimum quantity lubrication (MQL) does not necessarily lie on a straight line between dry machining and “wet” machining with flood coolant. The commonly held view that MQL is a compromise between these two approaches is a misperception because MQL is different from both. In fact, in the right applications, MQL is better than both.

For example, tool life can be longer with MQL than with either of the other choices. The lubricity of the oil that is applied in small quantities in MQL is greater than that of high-volume, water-based flood coolant. The same lubricity also facilitates chip clearance because a chip soaked in coolant can acquire both added weight and adhesion that make it more difficult to clear away.

But MQL also poses challenges, and one of these is the extent to which the lubricant has to accurately hit the tool.

MQL is also called “near-dry machining.” It applies cutting fluid in ounces instead of gallons, replacing flood coolant with atomized droplets of oil (usually vegetable-based). With properly equipped spindle and tooling, this oil can be delivered right through the tool. However, the more basic approach to MQL is to deliver the lubricant through external nozzles—in which case the aim of these nozzles becomes paramount. While flood coolant can hit the tool within an inch, the margin of error for MQL is more like a millimeter, says Chris Haugen, a sales manager for lubricant supplier ITW Rocol. If the flow of microdroplets misses, then machining near-dry turns into just plain machining dry.

ITW Rocol’s Accu-Lube products include a compact, positive-displacement pump system for adding MQL to an existing machining center. Mr. Haugen currently sees the most use of this system in mold and die shops.  The system works well in these shops because of the need to keep nozzles accurately pointed. Die/mold machine tools are likely to be manned—so an operator is available to move the nozzle if needed—and tool changes are infrequent, meaning the nozzle that does get moved by hand can be left in place through the course of a long cut.

However, near-dry machining can work with practically any workpiece material, and it works particularly well with modern carbide cutting tools. Mr. Haugen says there is no particular reason for it to be closely associated with die/mold machining. The benefits of add-on MQL could expand to a broader range of applications if only machine tools had better and more reliable nozzle aim. For this reason, the company recently partnered with programmable nozzle developer SpiderCool to deliver Accu-Lube MQL together with the SpiderCool nozzle system as part of a single installation.

SpiderCool uses servo control for nozzle positioning. When a tool is used for the first time, the operator adjusts the nozzle position using a tuning knob. A beam of light indicates where the nozzle aims. Once the proper targeting is found, the system remembers that tool’s pocket number so it can return the nozzle to that position automatically each time the tool is loaded. While the system is often applied to flood coolant, near-dry machining can become practically hands-free when it is applied to MQL, says Mr. Haugen. Nozzle aim no longer has to be watched or adjusted during the cycle. In fact, thanks to the servo control, the system can be used to give the nozzle a slight oscillation—flicking the slick, lubricated chips out of the way of the cut.

Perhaps surprisingly, Mr. Haugen says it is not the greater tool life or reduced fluid costs that he sees most shops pursue. These savings can be hard to quantify in advance if the shop has no prior MQL experience. Instead, the typical user simply prefers to run clean.

This cleanliness is the main motive for MQL, he says. Lighter use of cutting fluid results in both a cleaner machine and a cleaner shop (even a better-smelling shop at that). The value of this cleanliness in terms of both customer impression and employee morale may be even more difficult to quantify than the tool and coolant savings. However, the value is real, and it seems to be the most significant return on investment that shops are seeking through near-dry machining.