NTMA
Published

The Education Gap

Academic institutions have a responsibility to provide a comprehensive education to students, making them employable.

Share

You’ve seen it haven’t you? Maybe you ignored it or thought it was just this one candidate, but then the next one was the same. And the next one. And the next one. If you work in manufacturing or machining, you know that I am talking about the massive skills gap that exists in our industry, the skills gap that is stunting the growth and success of our companies. While there is not enough skilled labor out there to meet the current demand, the issue we are facing is bigger than that; the skills gap is only part of the problem. What’s the other part? It’s something that is going to continue to make things worse for the industry: the “education gap.”

The education gap can be defined as the gap between what an employee needs to know to make a company competitive and what is actually being taught in schools, tech programs and academic institutions. Let me explain within the framework of machining: Most institutions have not updated their curriculums to reflect the changing nature of the industry, meaning graduates are not being properly equipped with the skills they need to compete for jobs today and in the future.

There is something to be said when it comes to teaching people the foundations, but those foundations must reflect the industry of tomorrow, not the machine shop of 50 years ago. Schools keep emphasizing outdated skills, like the use of shapers. Guess what? It is a complete waste of time. I cannot remember the last time I saw a shaper, much less used one. The sad part is that learning to use a shaper is just one of the many outdated skills that are still being taught today due to outdated curriculum demands. Precious time is being wasted on these skills when the actual skills students need to know, like geometric dimensioning and tolerancing (GD&T) and automation, are being neglected. 

Those of us in the industry know how GD&T in drawings is becoming a standard in manufacturing, yet a limited number of educational institutions have even added it as part of their machinist programs. This is the education gap, and not understanding something like GD&T is becoming a very real and significant issue. If this issue gets out of control, parts will not meet the exacting specifications because the machinist and the company doing the manufacturing do not understand the drawings.

GD&T is just one piece of the bigger picture, and the bigger picture is automation. We know this, yet institutions still refuse to add it to their standard curriculums. Now, I can already hear someone challenging me by saying, “Hold up. There are a ton of schools with computer numerical controls (CNCs), so they already teach automation.” I have heard this spiel before. What these schools have is outdated technology from the 1980s, and they just call it automation. While they are technically right, relying on technicalities does not help the students. So, while this technology is “automation,” it is irrelevant. Using this logic, you could argue that factories from the early 1900s with belts running from the ceiling to drive the equipment is automation. Automation is being redefined constantly as new technology is introduced. Today, automation involves multi-pallet, multi-axis machines and robotics, and the machinist who cannot run this equipment will be unemployable.

Yes, this technology is expensive, but students are investing in an education that will make them employable. That is what school is all about. Institutions have a responsibility, and they cannot promise a comprehensive education if they do not have the tools to make it a reality. Machinists are no longer tradesmen. Today’s machinists are technologists. They have to adapt to new technologies and learn new skills. Adding robots to a machine shop is difficult, but with the proper education and know-how, there is no need to fear this technology. It is like any new thing: When you do not understand it, you fear it.

The education gap is preventing progress and hindering the success of so many machine shops. Up-and-comers need to understand the new technologies and processes. If they do not understand them, they will not adopt them, and they will not be employable. Instead, they fear automation and contribute to the potential failure of a machine shop. We need to start in institutions and equip future machinists with the skills they need rather than irrelevant skills and “automated processes” from the 1980s.

Become a NTMA member today!
NTMA
NTMA
Gardner Business Media, Inc.
IMTS+
DN Solutions
MMS Made in the USA
715 Series - 5-axis complete machining
Koma Precision
PMTS 2025 Register Now!
Innovative Manufacturing for the Medical Industry
More blasting. Less part handling.

Related Content

Five-Axis

Building Machines and Apprenticeships In-House: 5-Axis Live

Universal machines were the main draw of Grob’s 5-Axis Live — though the company’s apprenticeship and support proved equally impressive.

Read More
Top Shops

Finding Skilled Labor Through Partnerships and Benefits

To combat the skilled labor shortage, this Top Shops honoree turned to partnerships and unique benefits to attract talented workers.

Read More

When Handing Down the Family Machine Shop is as Complex as a Swiss-Turned Part

The transition into Swiss-type machining at Deking Screw Products required more than just a shift in production operations. It required a new mindset and a new way of running the family-owned business. Hardest of all, it required that one generation let go, and allow a new one to step in.

Read More

DN Solutions Responds to Labor Shortages, Reshoring, the Automotive Industry and More

At its first in-person DIMF since 2019, DN Solutions showcased a range of new technologies, from automation to machine tools to software. President WJ Kim explains how these products are responses to changes within the company and the manufacturing industry as a whole.    

Read More

Read Next

Sponsored

The Future of High Feed Milling in Modern Manufacturing

Achieve higher metal removal rates and enhanced predictability with ISCAR’s advanced high-feed milling tools — optimized for today’s competitive global market.

Read More
Toolholders

Rego-Fix’s Center for Machining Excellence Promotes Collaboration

The new space includes a showroom, office spaces and an auditorium that will enhance its work with its technical partners.

Read More

Registration Now Open for the Precision Machining Technology Show (PMTS) 2025

The precision machining industry’s premier event returns to Cleveland, OH, April 1-3.   

Read More
NTMA