IMCO
Published

Reaming Application Illustrates True Cost of Cutting Tools

Cutting tools have two costs: purchase price and combined cost of all time, effort and extra steps required for a particular tool.

Share

Every time a machining facility purchases a cutting tool, that facility pays for the tool in two different ways.
 
First comes the purchase price. This number is very easy to know—the tool vendor states it directly. Many manufacturers stop their analysis here.
 
But then comes the second price, which is the combined cost of all of the time, effort and extra steps that this particular tool requires. This second price is invisible without careful analysis, even though it generally contributes much more to the total cost of the tool. The most cost-effective production plants tend to be those that are the very best at tracking the true, total cost of each tool.
 
Cutting tool supplier Iscar recently shared an example of an auto-industry manufacturer that performed precisely this analysis on the tooling in a crucial boring operation. Iscar’s national deep-hole drilling and reaming product manager Tom Edler says that even though the price differences seem extreme in this analysis, the numbers actually offer a fairly typical picture of how far high-performance tooling can go to deliver savings. Based on the analysis, the customer chose to abandon a tool with a price of less than $5 per insert in favor of a tool with a price of around $200 per insert. The secondary cost savings made the new tool the clear cost leader, even though the purchase price was 40 times more.
 
The specific application involved a blind bore machined in an injector body on a CNC turning machine. The workpiece material made gummy chips. These chips would pack into the hole and would sometimes get caught between the hole and the boring bar. Without warning, the part could fail to meet specifications, so the plant had to inspect every piece.
 
Iscar proposed replacing the boring bar with a very different tool. The company’s “Bayo T-Ream” is a reaming system with an interchangeable carbide head and a steel shank with a quick-change bayonet mechanism. Internal coolant holes direct fluid onto each of the head’s six cutting edges. This fluid, in combination with the geometry of the flutes, forces material to flow up and out of the cut. The design of this reaming head is complex compared to a single-point boring insert, accounting for the higher price. But the manufacturer discovered the cost savings to be even higher still.
 
The first area of savings was in the quantity of inserts purchased, Iscar says. Tests demonstrated that one reaming head delivered five times the tool life of a boring insert in terms of the number of workpieces machined.
 
Further savings came from the various secondary cost factors mentioned above, including time, effort and extra steps. Specifically:
 
• Time. The reaming head has six flutes, whereas the boring tool cuts with just one edge. For the same chip load, feed rate could be increased by a factor of six. The operation is now performed in one-sixth the time.
 
• Effort. Shorter tool life meant the process had to be stopped more frequently so the insert could be changed—particularly since the full life of the boring insert involves an index from one cutting edge to another. The reaming system reduced both tool setups and the frequency of reordering tools.
 
• Extra steps. The reaming system is so effective at controlling the gummy chips that the bore now consistently meets spec. The extra step of inspecting every piece—a step necessary entirely because of the previous boring system—has now been eliminated.
 
“Productivity is the great equalizer,” Mr. Edler says. This principal is even larger than cutting tools. At all levels, companies that base manufacturing decisions on purchase prices are seeing most of those prices increase. The key to overcoming these quoted prices is to find all of the unquoted cost savings that come from having a more productive process.
 

One caveat is that this search for savings often requires a change of thinking. Previously, the injector body manufacturer saw the critical hole as a boring application. The savings came when the company saw it as a reaming application instead. Something similar frequently occurs in milling work, Mr. Edler says. Many facilities can double their metal-removal rate in milling, but doing so requires the counterintuitive step of switching to a high-feed milling tool design that mandates a light depth of cut—lighter than what the shop is taking now. Running this tool at  a substantially higher feed rate can more than overcome the lighter cut to save overall cost. In applications such as these, he says, the cost-effective approach often looks very different from the way that a given part or feature has historically been machined.  

 

 

 

Sumitomo
Kyocera SGS
Specialized Plastic Packaging for Cutting Tools
Ingersoll Cutting Tools
IMCO
CERATIZIT
Iscar
Horn USA
High Accuracy Linear Encoders
QualiChem Metalworking Fluids
More blasting. Less part handling.
Innovative Manufacturing for the Medical Industry

Related Content

Milling Tools

Grooving Attachment Streamlines Operation by 75%

A grooving attachment enabled Keselowski Advanced Manufacturing to reduce cycle times by over 45 minutes on a high-value, high-nickel part feature.

Read More
Sponsored

How to Mitigate Chatter to Boost Machining Rates

There are usually better solutions to chatter than just reducing the feed rate. Through vibration analysis, the chatter problem can be solved, enabling much higher metal removal rates, better quality and longer tool life.

Read More

Orthopedic Event Discusses Manufacturing Strategies

At the seminar, representatives from multiple companies discussed strategies for making orthopedic devices accurately and efficiently.

Read More
Sponsored

Quick-Change Tool Heads Reduce Setup on Swiss-Type Turning Centers

This new quick-change tooling system enables shops to get more production from their Swiss turning centers through reduced tool setup time and matches the performance of a solid tool.

Read More

Read Next

5 Rules of Thumb for Buying CNC Machine Tools

Use these tips to carefully plan your machine tool purchases and to avoid regretting your decision later.

Read More

Registration Now Open for the Precision Machining Technology Show (PMTS) 2025

The precision machining industry’s premier event returns to Cleveland, OH, April 1-3.   

Read More
Toolholders

Rego-Fix’s Center for Machining Excellence Promotes Collaboration

The new space includes a showroom, office spaces and an auditorium that will enhance its work with its technical partners.

Read More
CERATIZIT